Changing managers: the law levels the playing field

A small community scheme in Adelaide voted to change manager. In the three days that followed, its outgoing manager declined to pay the scheme's insurance, stopped managing it overnight, stopped answering its owners, and quoted a handover period twelve times the legal limit. The building stayed insured throughout. This is how, and what any committee can take from it. Names, addresses and dates are left out; the facts are as they happened.
The case
The scheme's management contract had passed its end date and was running month to month on 30 days' notice. The manager held the corporation's common seal and the authority to operate its bank account. The corporation paid fixed annual fees, with hourly charges on top. Its building insurance was due for renewal in the same week as its annual general meeting.
Week 1. The committee met us. We asked for the current contract, which set the notice period, and the date the insurance fell due.
Week 7. The presiding officer convened the annual general meeting himself, on 14 days' written notice to every owner. The agenda ended the old contract, appointed Acacia, and let the corporation renew its own insurance within a premium cap.
Five days before the meeting. The outgoing manager's related insurance broker reported that an independent insurer was "unable to quote due to the by-laws", and went ahead with a renewal through an insurer of its choosing.
Meeting day. Every motion passed. The insurance was due to expire that afternoon.
Day 2. The presiding officer served notice ending the contract, 30 days out.
Day 3, morning. The corporation signed Acacia's agreement electronically. The independent insurer read the registered by-laws, bound cover, and agreed to hold payment. The presiding officer asked the outgoing manager to cancel the related renewal and to pay the new premium from the corporation's funds.
Day 3, midday. The outgoing manager declined to pay any invoices: "your new manager can do that".
Day 3, afternoon. Offered a choice between paying and ending the engagement early, the manager stopped managing the scheme that day. It said the books would follow within 120 business days, that the corporation lacked the funds to pay the premium, and asked its broker to cancel the policy.
Day 3, 4pm. Told in writing that the Act allows 7 business days for the money and 10 for the records, the manager said its accounts team would see "if this is possible". It added that all calls and emails from clients would be ignored from 5pm.
Day 3, evening. Acacia sent a one-page variation bringing its start forward to the next morning. The presiding officer told every owner who to call from now on, and to stop paying levies to the outgoing manager.
At the time of writing the building is insured, Acacia starts the next morning, every owner knows who to call, and the corporation's money and records are due back within 7 and 10 business days. Whether the outgoing manager meets those dates is now between it and the Act. The corporation's management cost falls by about a third, with no hourly charges.
The pattern
None of it was improvised. Three months earlier a strata scheme left the same manager, and the moves were the same ones in a different order. Each pushes the cost of leaving onto the corporation that is leaving, in the hope the committee finds it cheaper to stay.
Leave before the notice runs
How it showed up. The community scheme's manager stopped acting the day after it was told to pay a bill. The strata scheme's left early too.
What answered it. Treat it as an agreed early end, in writing, and start the new manager the next morning. The statutory clock for money and records starts the day the manager stops.
Hold the insurance
How it showed up. A related broker reported that an independent insurer could not quote, then renewed through an insurer of its own choosing. The manager declined to pay the premium the corporation chose. In the strata scheme, $305 left the corporation's account for the related broker with no instruction the corporation could find.
What answered it. Go to the independent insurer direct. It read the registered by-laws, quoted and bound cover. The decision to insure belongs to the corporation, and a general meeting can take it back from any manager.
Invent a timetable
How it showed up. "Within 120 business days, as per the Act." The Act says 10. The strata scheme's contract made the return of records conditional on payment, and allowed 30 days.
What answered it. Quote the regulation. Money within 7 business days, records within 10, and neither depends on any invoice being paid.
Charge for the exit
How it showed up. Both contracts carried a handover and exit fee, about $500 for a small scheme. On the strata scheme's meeting day the manager signed a new one-year agreement itself, which the owners never saw.
What answered it. Decline it in writing. Returning a corporation's records and money is a duty the Act imposes, and the Act sets no fee for it. An agreement the corporation never resolved to make binds nobody.
Go quiet
How it showed up. With about an hour's warning, the manager announced that it would ignore every call and email from clients. Asked about the statutory deadlines, it would only see whether meeting them was possible.
What answered it. Have the new manager ready to start the next morning, and tell owners directly. The duties to return money and records run whether anyone reads their email or not, and missing them is an offence.
The common thread is the corporation's own money and its own paperwork, held by someone who has been told to give them back. Every one of these moves falls over once a committee knows the contract and the Act better than the manager expects it to.
What the law says
A committee in South Australia can rely on six rules. None of them needs the outgoing manager's cooperation.
Calling the meeting. The presiding officer can call a general meeting without the manager, on 14 days' written notice to every owner. Changing manager is an ordinary resolution. (Community Titles Act 1996, s 81)
Ending the contract. The notice period is whatever the contract says. Once the contract ends, every delegation under it ends too. (s 78A(5)(c)(i))
Money and records. The manager must return the corporation's money within 7 business days of its delegations ending, and its records within 10. Neither waits for an invoice to be paid. (s 78D(6); Community Titles Regulations 2026, reg 16)
Insurance. A delegation never stops the corporation doing the job itself. It can choose and place its own insurance whoever holds the delegation. (s 78A(5)(b))
Signing. The corporation can sign without its manager or its seal. Two of its three officers sign, or one, where one person holds all three offices. (s 73)
Disputes. A dispute with a manager can go to the Magistrates Court. (Part 14)
Strata schemes have matching rules in the Strata Titles Act 1988, including the duty to return money and records at s 27D(6), with the same 7 and 10 business days in the regulations. Before relying on a rule for a particular scheme, read the current text of the Act and the scheme's own contract. Sections get renumbered, and contracts differ.
For the step-by-step process, see our guide How to change your strata manager.
Checklist for committees
Most of the work happens before the vote. A committee that has these lined up gives an outgoing manager nothing to hold.
Read the current contract. Find the end date, the notice period, any exit fee, who holds the common seal, and what it says about returning records.
Know when the insurance falls due. Get quotes from a broker with no tie to your manager before the meeting, and put a renewal motion with a premium cap on the agenda.
Call the meeting yourselves if you need to. Give 14 days' written notice to every owner, including owners who live elsewhere, at their address for service. Chase proxies early: quorum is what costs a fortnight.
Put it all on one agenda. End the old contract, appoint the new manager, set what is delegated, set controls on spending, decide the insurance, and fill any vacant office.
Serve notice the day the vote passes. Name the end date, the common seal, the money and the records, with the statutory deadline for each.
Instruct in writing, every time. Email, with the resolution it relies on. A phone call leaves nothing to point to.
Keep urgent payments away from the outgoing manager. If a premium falls due during the changeover, ask the insurer for payment terms first.
Sign the new agreement early, with a start date you can move. If the old manager leaves before its notice runs out, the new one can start the next morning.
The outgoing manager is relying on a committee that doesn't know its own rights. This one did.
This is general information only. It is a practical reference, not legal advice, and it is not advice about any insurer or policy. Speak to a licensed insurance broker or adviser about your own scheme.
Have questions about strata?
Get in touch and we'll help with your strata needs.
