Skip to content
Acacia Collective
ABC News

From a 64 per cent broker fee to the Supreme Court: what the Netstrata case means for owners

Acacia Collective17 November 20267 min read
From a 64 per cent broker fee to the Supreme Court: what the Netstrata case means for owners

In 2018 the owners of a Brighton-Le-Sands apartment building were told their building insurance had cost $12,900. One owner, a retired engineering instructor, asked for the actual bill. The premium was $6,197.32. A broker fee of $4,000 had been added by Strata Insurance Services, a broker wholly owned by the building's strata manager, Netstrata. Allowing for GST, he worked the fee out at about 64 per cent of the premium. When the owners said they would complain to the authorities, Netstrata refunded it.

That story led an ABC Investigations report by Linton Besser and Ninah Kopel, published on 21 Mar 2024. Two and a half years later, the company and its managing director are facing criminal charges in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

What the ABC reported

Netstrata manages more than 1,000 buildings and 35,000 apartments across NSW. At the time its managing director, Stephen Brell, was also NSW president of the Strata Community Association, the industry body. The ABC set out three kinds of arrangement, drawing on Netstrata's financial statements, its reports to clients and former staff.

  • Insurance broker fees. The 2022 Trowbridge review of strata insurance found broker fees commonly ran at 5 to 15 per cent of the base premium. The ABC confirmed that Netstrata's broker had charged 60 per cent or more on at least two occasions, and calculated from the company's own returns that its average fee had been between about 31 and 52 per cent in the years it examined. Netstrata's client reports said its broker "does not receive commissions". The ABC reported that the company had taken more than $21 million in broker fees since 2015.

  • Related-party contractors. Netstrata owns a fire safety company, WinFire, which runs a maintenance business and a plumbing business. The ABC reported that these were routinely used without referral to the owners or competing quotes, and confirmed that staff had been offered $500 gift vouchers in 2021 for moving buildings to WinFire. Brell first denied the incentives existed, then said they had been stopped.

  • Referral fees. Netstrata received payments from other suppliers, which its disclosure statements called "commercial arrangements". The ABC confirmed at least one deal at 7.5 per cent of the fees clients paid. Netstrata's reports said these fees would be disclosed and approved through the report itself; the ABC inspected several and found no case where the amount appeared. Brell called this "a flaw in our process".

Brell told the ABC that Netstrata's fees were consistent with market rates and that its advice was that its disclosures were accurate. He rejected "kickbacks" as a description of the referral fees. The ABC's view at the time was that most of this appeared to be permitted under NSW law.

What happened next

The law changed. In September 2024 the NSW Parliament passed the Strata Managing Agents Legislation Amendment Act 2024, with its remaining provisions in force from 3 Feb 2025. Strata managers in NSW now need a general meeting resolution before accepting a commission, cannot take an insurance commission where the owners arranged and paid for their own cover, and can be ordered by the tribunal to repay commissions they did not disclose. We covered the reforms in What NSW's Strata Shake-Up Means for South Australian Owners.

The regulator looked. NSW Fair Trading appointed McGrathNicol to review Netstrata's management of 60 strata plans. The report, released in February 2025, was reported to have found failures to obtain two quotes for work over $30,000 and undisclosed commissions, both breaches of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW).

Charges were laid. On 9 Jul 2026 NSW Fair Trading announced criminal proceedings under the Property and Stock Agents Act 2002 (NSW) against Network Strata Services Pty Ltd and Mr Brell, as its director and licensee in charge. Fair Trading alleges they breached a strata managing agent's statutory obligations, failed in their fiduciary duties by not adequately disclosing or managing conflicts of interest (including with related-party service providers) and receiving undisclosed benefits, and gave false or misleading information to the regulator. Netstrata has said it will defend the charges. Brell has stepped aside as managing director while the case runs, and founder Ted Middleton has returned as acting managing director.

The case was listed for two days from 27 Jul 2026. Trade press reported that the first day was taken out of the court list. As at 17 Nov 2026 we have found no public report of pleas or an outcome. These are allegations, they have not been tested in court, and nothing here is a view on how the case should be decided.

The South Australian position

South Australia has no strata regulator to run an investigation like this one. It does have law on exactly this conduct.

Under section 27D of the Strata Titles Act 1988 (SA), anyone acting under a delegation from the corporation, including a strata manager, who has a direct or indirect pecuniary interest in a matter must disclose it to the corporation in writing before acting on it. Section 78D of the Community Titles Act 1996 (SA) says the same for community title, with a maximum penalty of $15,000. Both Acts give a worked example that could have been written for the Netstrata story: a manager who would earn a commission for placing the corporation's business, or who would profit by placing it with a related company, commits an offence by not disclosing that before placing it. An interest held by the manager's employee or agent counts as the manager's own.

Disclosure is required before the business is placed, in writing, to the corporation. A line in an annual report saying a related company "may" be used, or a brokerage figure folded into a premium, is a long way from that.

What to ask your manager

  • Insurance. Ask for the insurer's invoice, not just the total. It should show the base premium, any broker fee and any commission as separate amounts, and who receives each.

  • Related companies. Ask whether the manager, or any company related to it, owns or is paid by any contractor the building uses. Ask for the answer in writing.

  • Referral and panel fees. Ask whether any supplier pays the manager for referrals, for a place on a panel, or for anything else, and how much.

  • Quotes. For larger jobs, ask for the competing quotes the committee considered, not just the one that was chosen.

  • Your money. In a strata corporation, section 27D(5) entitles a unit holder to apply for a quarterly statement of the manager's dealings with the corporation's money.

Our guides to reading a management agreement and approving a major repair go into more detail.

Why the structure matters

Every arrangement in the ABC's report earned the manager money from decisions it made on the owners' behalf. Disclosure rules make those arrangements visible, which is worth having. They don't remove the reason to make them.

Acacia Collective is Australia's first member-owned strata and community title management collective. The owners corporations, bodies corporate and community corporations we look after are our members, and there are no outside shareholders for a broker fee or a referral deal to profit. If you would like to talk about how your building is managed, call us on 1300 792 255.

This is general information only, not legal advice and not advice about any insurer, broker or policy. Acacia Collective does not hold an Australian Financial Services Licence. Speak to a licensed insurance broker or adviser about your own scheme.


Sources: Linton Besser and Ninah Kopel, "High-profile strata company Netstrata caught charging excessive fees and taking kickbacks", ABC News, 21 Mar 2024; NSW Fair Trading, "NSW Fair Trading commences prosecution against Netstrata", 9 Jul 2026; Insurance Business, 10 Jul and 27 Jul 2026; Real Estate Business, 27 Feb 2025. The charges against Netstrata and Mr Brell have not been tested in court. South Australian law as at the version in force from 9 Dec 2021.

Have questions about strata?

Get in touch and we'll help with your strata needs.